| First Team | |||
| Name |
Class
|
School
|
Hometown/High School |
| Dan Allen | Jr. | Geneseo | Delmar/Albany Academy |
| Dan Callinan | Fr. | Oswego | Rock Tavern/Washingtonville |
| Andrew Chevalier | Fr. | Cortland | Chazy/Chazy Central Rural |
| Scott Horsington | Fr. | Fredonia | Rochester/Churchville-Chili |
| Dan Kelly | Jr. | Geneseo | Huntington/Harborfields |
| Dominick Mancini | So. | Oswego | Rochester/Irondequoit |
| Andrew McLellan | Sr. | Oswego | Manlius/Fayetteville-Manlius |
| Mike Wiese | So. | Geneseo | Buffalo/Kenmore West |
| Kent Yeung | Jr. | New Paltz | Flushing/Bayside |
| Second Team | |||
| Name |
Class
|
School
|
Hometown/High School |
| Tim Alongi | Sr. | Oswego | Auburn/Auburn |
| Patrick Connolly | Fr. | Cortland | Shrub Oak/Lakeland |
| P.J. Dunn | So. | Geneseo | Pittsford/Pittsford Sutherland |
| Greg Esler | So. | Brockport | Rochester/Aquinas Institute |
| Josh Hinman | So. | Geneseo | Weedsport/Weedsport |
| T.J. Hirsch | Sr. | Geneseo | Getzville/Williamsville North |
| Pat McNelis | Sr. | Geneseo | Rochester/Aquinas |
| Fernando Nussenbaum | Jr. | Geneseo | West Henrietta/Rush-Henrietta |
| Rory O'Reilly | So. | Geneseo | Rye/Rye |
| Jack Popper | Jr. | Cortland | Merrick/Bellmore JFK |
| Jon Singer | So. | Oswego | Endicott/Union-Endicott |
| Evan Smith | So. | Geneseo | Pine Bush/Pine Bush |
| Jon Sousa | Sr. | New Paltz | Albany/Albany |
| Tim Stockton | So. | Geneseo | Fairport/Fairport |
| Philip Szrama | Fr. | Geneseo | Orchard Park/Orchard Park |
| Nate Youmell | Sr. | Brockport | Weedsport/Weedsport |